Issue 7 Failure Summer 2002
Beautiful Indonesia (In Miniature)
On a rainy day in November, at the Beautiful Indonesia in Miniature Park, two nearly-naked men from Irian Jaya (the Indonesian half of the island of New Guinea) sit on the cold marble floor in the main pavilion. Their dark faces are streaked with red and yellow ochre. Crescent-shaped bones hang from their noses. They sit with their long, banded arms wrapped around their knees, smoking cigarettes and arguing. In front of them a Balinese dancer stares wide eyed into the middle distance. Without turning her head she looks from right to left to right. Her forefingers flutter like hummingbirds, beating quadruple time to the rhythm of the gamelan. These performances are one of the few things in Indonesia that always take place on time, whether anyone is there to see them or not. As long as they continue, culture is alive and well in Indonesia—or at least that is the official position.
The most remarkable thing about Taman Mini is that it was built at all. Taman Mini cost $25 million—a preposterous amount of money in Indonesia in 1971. A group of officials objected to the project, pointing out that for the same price the government could build 52 small industries or seven large universities. Public protests drew large crowds and reached a climax when the "Save Our People's Money" movement marched on Tien's "Our Hope" foundation. The army opened fire with live ammunition and at least four people were seriously wounded. Suharto finished the clash with characteristic subtlety, saying of the dissenters, "Quite frankly, I'll deal with them. No matter who they are!"1
Why would the leader of a struggling republic risk public outrage and financial ruin to build a theme park his wife dreamed up at Disneyland? Suharto himself addressed the question at the dedication on 20 April 1975. "Life," he said, "will not have a beautiful and deep meaning with material sufficiency only… One's life will be calm and complete only when it is accompanied by a spiritual welfare. The direction and guidance toward that spiritual welfare is, in fact, already in our possession; it lies in our beautiful and noble national cultural inheritance."2This remark gives a clue as to the true function Taman Mini would come to serve for the government. Beautiful Indonesia in Miniature Park was not built to be an amusing diversion. Rather, it would serve as the nation's spiritual treasure trove—a locked box containing the nation's cultural wealth to be kept close to Indonesia's heart and its capital. Suharto's definition of culture would be elucidated by the festivities that followed.
In addition to the foreign dignitaries, the governors of Indonesia's territories were recalled to Jakarta for Taman Mini's dedication ceremony. As the representative of the cultures of that region, each of the governors were required by Suharto to dress in a customary costume. Under these orders, the governor of Irian Jaya wore a fur crown and put a bone through his nose. (This, of course, hardly obscured the fact that he was not a dark-skinned native of Irian Jaya, but a light-skinned Javanese.) The other governors, who were similarly costumed, were Javanese as well. Though the effect of all these pale, pudgy Javanese bureaucrats dressed up like jungle warriors must have been comical, it seems safe say that, given the pious tone of the proceedings, no one laughed—except, perhaps, for Suharto himself. For Suharto, the masquerade was an ideological victory with far-reaching implications. He had succeeded in separating the idea of culture from the people who practiced it. Culture was now a costume that could be taken on or off, depending on the occasion.
Suharto would soon drop his mask. Having secured his position as a champion of culture in Indonesia, he would seize the land and resources of the outer islands and set about to dilute and destroy the people whose culture he had so recently celebrated. These policies would cost hundreds of thousands of lives and fuel the violent separatist movements that now threaten to break Indonesia apart. By the time Taman Mini was completed, the national government had already begun to claim locally held property. The Forest Development Law removed control of the nation's forests from the communities and gave it to the national government. The results were devastating. In 1966, when Suharto took power, 75 percent of Indonesia, or 144 million hectares, were covered in forest. By the time Suharto was removed from power in 1998, only 53 million hectares, or 37 percent, of the land remained forested. Indonesia had lost its rain forest at more than twice the world average. Suharto pushed the government authority into the most isolated regions of Sumatra, Sulawesi, Kalimantan and Irian Jaya. Huge camps were created in the middle of the jungle. Workers were brought in from Java and Madura. The money went to Jakarta. Tien Suharto even earned the nickname "Mrs. Ten Percent" because of the cut she took on business deals. When Suharto left office his successor estimated his fortune at $45 billion—enough to repay Indonesia's debts to the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. Taman Mini and the cultural policies it represented had paid for themselves many times over.
Suharto's policies brought equal devastation upon the people. Hundreds of thousands of people who resisted the authority of the Indonesian government were tortured and killed in East Timor, Irian Jaya, Aceh, and elsewhere. Recognizing that culture, though officially entombed at Taman Mini, might still be an organizing force, Suharto pushed a policy designed to dilute these populations. The program was called transmigrasi. Transmigrasi consisted of moving people from the densely populated islands such as Java to the outer islands. As many as 3.5 million people were lured by the promise of free land and housing but in fact found themselves stranded in isolated communities consisting of tiny, tin-roofed houses laid down at the edge of the jungle. Like canaries in a coalmine, the immigrants were used to inform the government of local hostility. When the hostility reached the boiling point, they would let the government know by dying.
The participants in transmigrasi have been the victims of some of the most extreme ethnic violence. On one island alone, Kalimantan, members of the Dyak ethnic group—the famed "Wild men of Borneo"—have slaughtered more than 550 immigrants in numerous attacks. Claiming a revival of ancient headhunting practices, they leave the headless corpses of men, women, and children strewn about the dirt streets. Although they seem to fancy themselves warriors descending from the forest primeval, they are several decades too late for that. In reality, most of these killers lived a life that was remarkably close to their victims–struggling to eke a living from a land that had been reduced to red dirt and saw grass.
In May of last year, the Beautiful Indonesia in Miniature Park held a mock Dyak wedding. At more or less the same time, the Dyaks held a mass execution in Kalimantan. Both of these events were seen as a celebration of Dyak culture by the people who staged them. Neither has much to do with the hunters and gatherers who once lived in the world's second largest rain forest and developed a complex system of rituals and beliefs that were in harmony with a world that has now almost entirely vanished. Beautiful Indonesia in Miniature has overtaken beautiful Indonesia.
David Womack was a Darmasiswa scholar in Indonesian literature and Javanese language at the Universitas Gadjah Mada in Yogyakarta, Java.
Cabinet is published by Immaterial Incorporated, a non-profit organization supported by the Lambent Foundation, the Orphiflamme Foundation, the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs, the National Endowment for the Arts, the New York State Council on the Arts, the Danielson Foundation, the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, the Katchadourian Family Foundation, and many generous individuals. All our events are free, the entire content of our many sold-out issues are on our site for free, and we offer our magazine and books at prices that are considerably below cost. Please consider supporting our work by making a tax-deductible donation by visiting here.
© 2002 Cabinet Magazine